Girl Reading Magazine

Tin House Issue 74, Winter 2017

This Tin House carried stories with a satirical edge to them. The ones that stayed away from the dystopic and satirized reality worked the best. A number of these stories were only a few pages while others extended nearly twenty. They ranged from highly experimental to relatively traditional. The Winter 2017 Tin House had one particular stand out story, “Mendelssohn,” that makes buying this issue worth it alone. Overall though, most of the stories left me befuddled, rather than rewarded and satisfied.

Tin House Winter 2017 Issue 74

The Stories from Tin House Issue 74

“The Wolves” by Kseniya Melnik

Two Wolves

Often, Tin House implies that its best story comes first in the issue by putting the most famous authors up front (see Aimee Bender’s story in X issue). If that’s true, it only proves how subjective the publishing world is, as this was one of the stranger stories I’ve read recently. It begins with a girl being chased by wolves in a forest during the Great Purge in Russia. She stumbles upon a cabin, where she meets a man she’s known from the past. They have an enigmatic conversation. At the end of the story, the narrator/daughter/writer reveals that she’s relating a story her grandmother told her from her past. It gets meta and ends with her wanting to understand the metaphor of the story, with her grandmother saying that it isn’t one. It’s confusing. 2 Stars.

“She Was Warned” by Leni Zumas

This short story follows a female narrator approaching menopause who hopes to have a child. Unmarried, she looks at a variety of options for having children but recent law changes and a general cultural bias towards two parent households makes her dreams almost pointless.

Oddly, the writer throws in a dystopic aspect, with new laws like the Personhood Amendment, which bands abortion and make it illegal to transfer artificially inseminated embryos to a uterus. The character’s struggles felt real world enough to not require the dystopic layer. It made the story more didactic than it had to be and dampened its potential. Its message that women often struggle against the biological clock and struggle through the bureaucracy of adoption or other means to have children became less impactful. 3 Stars

“Mendelssohn” by Seth Fried

To read the full review, click here. 5 Stars

“Communications” by Sofi Stambo

To read the full review, click here. 4 Stars

“The Cage” by Tania James

About two pages long, this piece follows a family rearing its first young child. The story is a meditation on the community of young parents, specifically mothers, who deal with that comes with the dangers and difficulties of a baby’s crib life. It moves from one family,to a larger friend group, and then to all of the mothers engaging in a similar struggle. It had fun, specific moments but it fell flat for me. 2 Stars

“At the Center” by Delaney Nolan

Pillows and Sheets

This story has a biting tone that utilizes a fantastic premise that works better than “She Was Warned.” The protagonist works at The Dream Center, a rehab facility for those addicted to taking a medication that makes it possible to live without sleep. The story satirizes the trend towards productivity at all costs. Even with its broad aims, it stays focused on its social worker protagonist and her patient. It’s a nice story, but some of the characterization felt like filler rather than something invaluable. 3.5 Stars

One Story Carries the Issue

For this issue, “Mendehlssohn” is without question the runaway winning story. Its use of humor and its ability to represent the ups and downs of a remembered relationship make it a remarkable piece of fiction. Overall, it’s a solid issue of Tin House, but Seth Friend’s story takes it over the top.

Tin House Issue 74 Winter Reading Book Cover Tin House Issue 74 Winter Reading
Rob Spillman
Literary Fiction
Tin House Magazine
Winter 2017

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.